Providing constructive feedback to authors is a key goal of peer review. To support research on evaluating and generating useful peer review comments, we introduce RevUtil, a dataset for measuring the utility of peer review feedback.
RevUtil focuses on four main aspects of review comments:
Actionability β Can the author act on the comment?
Grounding & Specificity ββ¦ See the full description on the dataset page:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/boda/RevUtil_human.